The Employee Survival Guide® is the no-nonsense employment law podcast made exclusively for employees. After 200+ episodes, we deliver the straight talk your employer and HR don’t want you to hear — covering every work and career issue that actually matters.
Hosted and produced by Mark Carey, a veteran employment lawyer with 29 years of experience who has litigated hundreds of cases — including class actions — in state and federal courts nationwide. Mark cuts through the BS with blunt, practical advice, always presenting both sides so you can make informed decisions. This podcast is also about your employment story and other courageous employees who have spoken out about their employers. If you work for a living, this is your podcast.
Now you can use our newly created AI agent to ask questions about your job and legal claims and receive answers based on our entire catalogue of podcast episodes and the full content from our extensive website.
Subscribe to our employee podcast show in your favorite podcast app including Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
If you enjoyed this episode of the Employee Survival Guide ® please like us on Facebook, X and LinkedIn. We would really appreciate if you could leave a review of this employee podcast on your favorite podcast player such as Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Thank you!
What happens when corporate rights overshadow individual beliefs in the workplace? Join attorney Mark Carey in this eye-opening episode of Employee Survival Guide® as he tackles the urgent and complex issues surrounding corporate personhood and religious freedom. With landmark cases like Burwell v. Hobby Lobby and Masterpiece Cake Shop as his backdrop, Mark sheds light on how corporations can assert religious beliefs that may infringe upon the rights of their employees religious freedom. Are we really living in a world where a corporation can claim religious exemptions while employees—who may hold differing beliefs—struggle to express their own views? This episode dives deep into the legal doctrines that treat corporations as 'persons,' allowing them to wield significant power over their workforce.
As we navigate the intricacies of employment law, Mark questions the fairness of this system, especially under laws like the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Are corporate entities really deserving of the same rights as individuals? The disparity is alarming, particularly in a workplace where issues like discrimination—whether it be race, gender, or disability—are already prevalent. Employees often find themselves grappling with hostile work environments, retaliation, and even sexual harassment, all while their corporate employers assert rights that may conflict with their own.
This episode of Employee Survival Guide® is not just another discussion about employment law; it's a rallying cry for employee empowerment and advocacy. Mark provides invaluable insights into navigating employment disputes, understanding workplace policies, and recognizing your rights as an employee. With practical tips on negotiating severance packages and understanding employment contracts, this episode equips you with the essential tools to survive and thrive in your career. Whether you're facing challenges in remote work or dealing with workplace harassment, Mark's candid advice will help you navigate the murky waters of employment law.
Don’t let corporate interests dictate your workplace experience. Tune in to this compelling episode and arm yourself with the knowledge you need to advocate for your rights and foster a healthier work culture. Because when it comes to employee survival, understanding the legal landscape is not just an advantage—it's a necessity. Listen now to learn how to not just survive, but truly thrive in your career.
If you enjoyed this episode of the Employee Survival Guide please like us on Facebook, X and LinkedIn.
We would really appreciate if you could leave a review of this podcast on your favorite podcast player such as Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Leaving a review will help other employees find the Employee Survival Guide.
Disclaimer: For educational use only, not intended to be legal advice.
Unknown:
Welcome to another edition of the Employee Survival Guide, where you can learn everything your employer does not want you to know about and more. Now, here's attorney Mark Carey. Hey, it's Mark here and welcome to the next edition of the Employee Survival Guide. In this episode today, we're going to talk about, Oh ye of little faith does the company I work for have more religious freedom than I do? When it comes to freedom of religious expression in the commercial context, the corporation you work for may have more rights than you do. How is this possible? Well, as you may know, there is a particular legal doctrine that regards corporate organizations as "persons". Although we all know corporations are not exactly people, the law treats them as if they were. This is what lawyers call a legal fiction. We know it's not literally true, but the law pretends is true to make things work. This particular legal fiction is a source of many unjust and inequitable laws. What is worse is that is so deeply ingrained in our jurisprudence that people no longer question it. They should definitely start as it applies to the topic of protections for religious expression. Our lawmakers in the United States Supreme Court have begun to take this legal fiction a bit too far. And the landmark case of Burwell v. Hobby Lobby in 2014, the Supreme Court ruled that closely held for profit corporations could be exempt from laws to which its owners object on religious grounds, if there is a less restrictive means of furthering the laws objective. This ruling turns on an absurdly broad interpretation of a federal law called the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. In Hobby Lobby, the Court recognized for the first time that a corporation could hold religious beliefs. While the decision does not explicitly state that corporations are protected by the free exercise of religion clause of the First Amendment of the Constitution, we can someday expect to see that innovation occurring, after all the other quote unquote people in this country have that right. It's only fair corporations are people to write, the court appears to base its reasoning in Hobby Lobby, in part on the idea that by ascribing personal religious freedoms to corporations, the law is protecting the religious freedoms of the corporation's owners. But what are the rights and beliefs of the workers who make a corporation possible, but whom are not privileged to own the company? Are their religious views considered when the company declares the tenets of its deeply held faith? No, not at all. The owners are presumably the only entities within the corporation that matter, even where the corporation employs 1000s of people. What if most of the employees who actually comprise the corporate entity hold entirely different religious beliefs than the owners? Why is a company Christian if its workers are mostly Hindu or vice versa? Can a corporation undergo a religious conversion? Apparently, the religious beliefs of a company are determined solely by the individual or individuals holding a controlling interest. Surprised plot twist, the court creates more privileges for the wealthy. This doctrine begs the question, if the owners of the corporation already have all the individual religious liberties that all other individuals have. Why do they get to carry their beliefs into the marketplace and exercise them as a corporate entity as well? The owners of closely held corporations now have an extra set of religious liberties not available to those who do not own corporations. What is the source of this extra set of religious progressives Hobby Lobby is not a lone anomaly. Apparently bakeries also may have been sincerely held religious beliefs that need protection. Recently in masterpiece cake shop Ltd vs. Colorado Civil Rights Commission in 2018, a private cake decorating business claimed that it had the right to ignore Colorado civil rights laws prohibiting discrimination based on a customer's sexual orientation. Because of its sincerely held religious beliefs. The court did not directly answer the question as to whether a business has a constitutional right to discriminate based on its owners religious beliefs. Instead, the court decided that in masterpiece, the Colorado law was unenforceable because the commission expressed an impermissible hostility towards the bakeries sincerely held religious convictions. Apparently, the fact that bakeries are simply commercial pastry manufacturers that cannot hold personal beliefs except for some absurd metaphysical alchemy was not an important fact the court needed to acknowledge in a case currently pending before the Supreme Court, Fulton versus city of Philadelphia, the supreme court must decide whether the Constitution protects private corporations right to discriminate against LGBTQ couples in violation of law. The plaintiff in Fulton is Catholic social services or CSS, an organization that that was hired as a contractor for the city of Philadelphia to place foster children in suitable homes. css believes it has the right to violate the contract with the city by intentionally discriminating discriminating against LGBTQ couples based on its religious beliefs without losing its contract. Holden challenges the long held doctrine that neutral laws that apply equally to religious and secular parties without singling out people of faith. For inferior treatment. Our constitutional CSS also challenges the government's right to regulate its own contractors in the public interest. While CSS should not be compelled to enter into a contract that will cause it to violate the religious beliefs of its organizers, when it voluntarily seeks to become a government contractor. It should not be exempt from the laws and regulations with which governs such contracts. It certainly should not be exempt from the terms of the contract and voluntarily entered in folden. css seeks to bend the public laws to conform to its religious beliefs in the sphere of public commercial activity, what interest is served by ascribing personal religious beliefs to an organization rather than asking the question, Does a private religious organization have the right to dictate how the government conducts its business? We should rather ask? Does any organization engage in commerce in a public market have the right to assert personal religious beliefs? to begin with? How will the Supreme Court's new religious conservative majority answer these questions? So given that our laws are carving out an expanding set of religious liberties for corporate entities in the public marketplace? What rights do the employees of a corporation have to exercise their religious preferences in the workplace? The answer almost none. While corporate entities controlled by people with religious views may enter the public marketplace and assert their religious prerogatives at the expense of the government and the general public. A worker in a corporation has very few rights to express or protect his or her sincerely held religious beliefs. under Title seven of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, Employers are required to provide a reasonable accommodation for an employee sincerely held religious beliefs or practices, but only if the accommodation needed does not impose an undue hardship on the employer. A reasonable religious accommodation is a modification to a company's policy or workplace that permits an employee to practice or express his or her religious beliefs. Accommodations often include minor schedule changes exemption from vaccinations on religious grounds, relaxation of dress codes, or lateral transfers. The key to understanding the employer's obligation to accommodate however, lies in the use of the term, quote, undue hardship, and quote, in this context, undue hardship is defined basically as any factor that disrupts the workplace in any way or that has a more than de minimis cost to the company. Thus, if an employer must incur an identifiable costs or under any inconvenience to his business, it may deny or ignore an employee's request for religious accommodation. Thus, while the Supreme Court has carved out vast areas, where a private corporation may assert its religious preferences in the public marketplace to defy the laws and regulations enacted by duly elected government bodies, in the interest of the public, an employee cannot assert his or her religious preferences at work, even in defiance of a private company's arbitrary and idiosyncratic policies. Unless the combination has no impact on the business whatsoever. Under the RFRA the government must how that a law is the least estrictive means of ccomplishing the law's purpose n order to enforce it in the ace of a private companies laim of religious imposition. f laws passed by democratically nacted bodies must yield to a orporation's religious references. Why doesn't a rivate company's policies have o yield to an individual's eligious convictions? answered he company has more religious reedom than it's an individual mployees in the American arketplace? corporations are ommercial entities formed by eave of the government. They re things not people. How do we now they are bought and sold egally, people cannot be bought r sold any longer in this ountry. When corporations are ormed, they must seek the ermission of the state and ocal government where they are ocated in order to operate tate and federal laws and egulations are specifically nacted to regulate, limit and ontrol the conduct of these ntities. They are not private ersons with individual iberties and beliefs. Very few orporations are owned and perated by a single individual. ost corporations involve a ultitude of individuals to unction, each with his or her wn sets of beliefs and iberties. Further, when one or ore individuals form a orporation. The primary bjective and chief benefit of he corporation formation is to hield the owners from ndividual liability. In ssence, the whole purpose of he corporate form is to legally istinguish the corporate entity rom the individuals that ontrol it. The Supreme Court nd rulings in Hobby Lobby and he ruling urged by the plants n Fulton would eliminate the ery distinction between owners nd entity that the law provided hen the Corporation was formed. hese rulings are not just llogical, they are undamentally inequitable. Let's tart treating corporations as hat they are things. If you'd ike more information about this opic, please contact Carey & ssociates PC on the web at ww.capclaw.com take care and I ook forward to talking to you n the next episode. Thanks